The defendant's lawyer said to the plaintiff's lawyer, "Lawyer Zhang, through our reasoning and verification just now, you and even the entire court agree with my point of view and agree that my client would not have had the opportunity to see this magazine in recent years. ! Now you are suddenly questioning the facts you previously believed. Don¡¯t you think it¡¯s a bit unreasonable and even a slap in the face?!¡±
"I admit that I didn't think carefully just now. I didn't expect you to be so insidious. You used the method of making false claims in the east to attack the west, which made me hard to guard against."
"Lawyer Zhang, what the court wants is evidence, reasonable evidence and reasonable reasoning. It's not just what I say. Please don't forget your duty as a lawyer!" the defendant lawyer sarcastically said. road.
"Your Honor." The plaintiff's lawyer didn't seem to want to get entangled with the defendant's lawyer. He said directly to the judge, "Just now, the defendant's lawyer has been maliciously leading us to admit his point of view. In fact, his point of view is full of loopholes. He has only sold 500 copies. , it is nonsense to say that it was circulated at that time and then disappeared. As long as the magazine circulates in the market, it can exist and circulate for as long as it takes, not just 8 years ago!"
"Your Honor." The defendant's lawyer also seemed a little excited. "The point I just made is not nonsense! The answer is only reasonable and reasonable through witness evidence, and the judge also agrees. Now the plaintiff's lawyer is making trouble unreasonably and arrogantly ¡¡±
"Your honor" the plaintiff's lawyer wanted to steal the conversation.
The defendant¡¯s lawyer said directly, ¡°I still have evidence to prove my client¡¯s innocence.¡±
¡°What evidence?¡± the judge asked the defendant¡¯s lawyer.
"I have a copy of all the design works I was engaged in in the design industry at that time, as well as the market recognition and feedback, and even won numerous international awards. It is evident that my client's design ability is definitely not on the same level as the plaintiff. And she is so outstanding, so With such a great reputation, what reason would she have to plagiarize other people's works? She knew that if she had such a great reputation, she would definitely be found out if she plagiarized, why would she take the risk?! It just doesn't make sense logically. The only possibility is that Bessie simply doesn't I know that the Angel series I designed is suspected of plagiarism!¡±
"I object!" the plaintiff's lawyer said excitedly, "All the defendant's lawyers' opinions are just reasoning and there is no evidence!"
"So, Lawyer Zhang, can you provide evidence to prove that my client has indeed seen the magazine that has disappeared from the market in the past four years, and that my client has indeed seen the original design of Phantom in the past four years."
"I" The plaintiff's lawyer was speechless.
"Lawyer Zhang, the court really needs evidence. Not only to defend my client's innocence, but also to convict my client, we need credible evidence to prove it. Otherwise, it will be just a speculation on your part, or rather, You are maliciously slandering!" The defendant's lawyer was very aggressive.
"You are talking nonsense!" The plaintiff's lawyer was speechless and extremely excited at this moment.
"Quiet!" The judge knocked the gavel, "This legal defense ends here. This court will determine the time of plagiarism and adjourn for half an hour!"
With that said, the judge and the bench were ready to leave.
"Your Honor!" The defendant's lawyer stepped forward and shouted, "Your Honor, I still have evidence to prove that my client did not plagiarize Phantom's work at all, but Phantom plagiarized other people's works!"
As soon as the words fell, the whole place was in an uproar.
This reversal is a bit scary.
The plaintiff has become the defendant.
Isn¡¯t this funny? !
But because of the unexpectedness of this moment, the whole scene became excited.
"Quiet!" The judge said seriously.
Everyone calmed down a little.
Xia Qiqi in the audience couldn't help but start to get excited.
The main event is finally here.
She couldn't help but look at Bessie.
Bessie was actually a little shocked at the moment.
She originally thought it would be over here.
All the communication between her and the lawyer ended here. No one ever told her that there would be these follow-ups.
"I object!" the plaintiff's lawyer loudly said, "This trial is only for Bessie's plagiarism case. Please, your honor, please do not extend it to other irrelevant cases!"
"Your honor, this concerns whether my client has plagiarized, who is the author of this original work, and whether Phantom has the qualifications to accuse my client of plagiarizing her work!"
"Allow." The judge nodded.
The defendant¡¯s lawyer saidJiao smiled.
The plaintiff¡¯s lawyer¡¯s face was naturally extremely ugly.
The defendant¡¯s lawyer said, ¡°Your honor, please allow me to be present as my witness.¡±
"allow."
This time it was a woman who walked in.
The woman is obviously older.
The defendant¡¯s lawyer asked, ¡°Who are you?¡±
"I am the former editor-in-chief of Tongli Design Agency." The woman said, "My name is Zhen Ni."
"Hello, Zhen Ni, I would like to ask if you have ever seen this work." The defendant's lawyer put the angel's design in front of Zhen Ni.
¡°I¡¯ve seen it before,¡± Zhen Ni replied.
"Have you seen it in this magazine?"
"No." Zhen Ni said bluntly, "This is the first time I have seen this magazine."
¡°As a person in the design circle, haven¡¯t you read this design magazine?¡±
"Shuiwen's design magazine was not in the mainstream back then, and very few were recognized by its peers. I didn't pay attention to their magazines, which is normal." Obviously, Zhen Ni has a certain status in the design circle of Beiwen Country, her tone Also rather arrogant.
"Okay." In fact, the defendant's lawyer just wanted to reiterate how unpopular this magazine was. He continued to ask, "Then when and where did you see this design?"
¡°This work appeared in a design competition 9 years ago.¡±
"Is the person participating in the competition the person you see now?" the defendant's lawyer pointed at Xu Shiqing.
"No." Zhen Ni was sure.
As soon as he finished speaking, there was some commotion at the scene.
"Who is that?" the defendant's lawyer asked.
"An Nuan." Zhen Ni replied, "Because her real name is required to participate in the competition, I know her real name is An Nuan."
Annuan
Xia Qiqi's eyes suddenly turned red in the audience.
How long has it been since I heard this name from an outsider?
"An Nuan?" The plaintiff's lawyer deliberately prolonged his tone, "Are you sure it's not the phantom in front of you, or your real name is Xu Shiqing?"
"I'm sure not." Zhen Ni said, "This competition is a live competition, and you need to be present in person to design. As a judge, of course I have met you. I am sure that the person here is An Nuan, not her." (Remember. Website address: www.hlnovel.com