Add Bookmark | Recommend this book | Back to the book page | My bookshelf | Mobile Reading

Free Web Novel,Novel online - All in hlnovel.com -> Prose -> Hello Miss Lawyer

Chapter 357 Husband and wife joint debt dispute (5)

Previous page        Return to Catalog        Next page

    ?

    Liu Bingxin inquired about the identity of the expert as usual.

    Liu Bingxin asked: "Please tell the appraiser your name, date of birth, work unit, etc."

    The appraiser nodded slightly, and then calmly said: "I am Lei Lei, born in February 1980, a practicing appraiser of Tianze Judicial Appraisal Institute."

    After all, put your ID card, work permit, and unit introduction letter on the witness stand.

    The bailiff stepped forward very professionally, and handed all three documents to Liu Bingxin. After Liu Bingxin checked them carefully, he ordered the bailiff to send the three documents to Lu Yiming and Lin Ziyao for review.

    Lu Yiming looked repeatedly at Lei Lei's ID card, work permit, and letter of introduction, and carefully checked with the identification information on the last page of the appraisal certificate. After about two minutes, he nodded to confirm Lei Lei's identity.

    Although Lin Ziyao hated Lu Yiming, he had to admit that Lu Yiming was very serious and careful.

    Lin Ziyao has no objection to Lei Lei's identity.

    Lu Yiming said to Liu Bingxin: "Presiding judge, I apply to ask questions to the expert."

    "Agreed." Liu Bingxin said.

    Lu Yiming looked at Lei Lei and asked, "May I ask the appraiser, what is the basis for you to make the signature of "Mr. Wang Tao" on the last page of the loan contract not his own signature?"

    Lei Lei smiled politely, and did not feel that she was offended by Lu Yiming's questioning. She said calmly, "The word 'Wang Tao' on the last page of this contract is different from the writing habits of the comparative inspection materials submitted by the court. I made  The ppt was used as an explanation, whether it needs to be screened in court."

    Everyone in the court did not expect Lei Lei to bring the ppt, and they were a little surprised.

    Liu Bingxin said, "I agree."

    Lei Lei even brought a stylus herself.

    The first ppt was divided into two. The left side is the signature of "Wang Tao" in the loan contract, which is the so-called inspection material; the right side is three comparative inspection materials.

    Lei Lei said: "You can take a look at a few comparative examination materials. It can be seen that Mr. Wang Tao wrote the stroke of "horizontal" from left to right, with a slight upward rise, but the "wang" in the loan contract is drawn from three strokes.  'Horizontal' are all on a horizontal plane, and at the end of the handwriting, there is a downward momentum."

    "In addition, the word 'Tao', compared with the word 'Tao' in the inspection materials, is higher than the word 'Shou' beside the three dots of water, but in the loan contract, the three dots of water in the character 'Tao' are obviously smaller than the word 'Shou' on the right.  'word." Lei Lei said.

    Then several ppts comparing the inspection materials were shown one after another.  Where Lei Lei explained, the ppt will be shown there, and the stylus will point there.

    It looks very professional and well-prepared.

    Everything is nothing more than the word "serious".

    Lin Ziyao admired Lei Lei's sense of professionalism and seriousness.

    Lu Yiming looked at Lei Lei's explanation as if he was giving a speech, and there was a strange smile on his face.

    Lei Lei explained her identification process and identification basis in detail, in simple terms, and everyone in the court seemed to have taken a lively handwriting identification course.

    ? Even Liu Bingxin and the clerk listened with great interest.

    Lin Ziyao felt that the way Lei Lei talked in court was simply shining.  Not because of how beautiful she is, but because of her excellent professionalism that makes her confident.

    Lu Yiming's face became ugly.

    However, after Lei Lei finished speaking, she asked Lu Yiming very gracefully: "Does the applicant have any questions?"

    Lu Yiming: ""

    He originally thought that he would find a breakthrough for Lei Lei's misidentification, but after listening for a long time, he seemed to be convinced by Lei Lei.

    Lu Yiming thought it was ridiculous.

    Liu Bingxin asked Lu Yiming: "Does the plaintiff have any other questions for the appraiser?"

    Lu Yiming said, "No."

    Liu Bingxin asked Lin Ziyao again: "Does the defendant have any questions for the appraiser?"

    Lin Ziyao was in a good mood, and even the tone of her answer was filled with a little joy. She said, "No."

    And cast a kind smile to the appraiser.

    Lei Lei exited the court, and Lu Yiming immediately said to Liu Bingxin: "Judge, the plaintiff, Chen Fan, has applied for a re-examination."

    Lin Ziyao immediately said: "Presiding judge, the defendant does not agree with the plaintiff's application for re-appraisal. Article 40 of the "Several Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Procedures" stipulates that if a party applies for re-appraisal under any of the following circumstances, the people's court shall  The court shall allow: (1) the appraiser does not have the corresponding qualifications; (2) the appraisal procedure seriously violates the law; (3) the appraisal opinion is obviously insufficient; (4)Other situations where the opinion cannot be used as evidence.  In this case, the above four conditions do not exist, and re-appraisal is unfair to the defendant and wastes litigation resources.  "

    The smile on Lu Yiming's face froze.

    Lin Ziyao's mouth curved even wider.

    Liu Bingxin thought for a moment and asked Lu Yiming: "Is there any legal reason for the plaintiff to apply for re-appraisal?"

    Lu Yiming: ""

    However, Lu Yiming has rich practical experience after all, he quickly adjusted his status, and said to Liu Bingxin: "The plaintiff thinks that the number of comparative examination materials for handwriting identification is not enough, and requests more comparative examination materials."

    Lin Ziyao immediately counterattacked: "No, the comparison of inspection materials was jointly determined by the plaintiff and the defendant, and now the plaintiff raises the issue of comparison of inspection materials, which has no legal basis."

    Liu Bingxin thought for a while and said, "The court will be adjourned for ten minutes. I need to think about it."

    These ten minutes were a long time for both Lu Yiming and Lin Ziyao; when their eyes met, Lu Yiming felt cold, but Lin Ziyao simply turned his face away.  If Ziyao feels offended, he will be offended, it's no big deal.

    When Liu Bingxin came back, Lu Yiming and Lin Ziyao immediately sat in the plaintiff's seat, waiting for Liu Bingxin to announce his decision.

    Liu Bingxin struck the gavel and said, "Continue with the court session."

    Under the watchful eyes of Lu Yiming and Lin Ziyao, Liu Bingxin said: "After consideration, the court decided not to approve the plaintiff's application for re-appraisal. The reasons are as follows: First, the selection of the appraisal agency is under the auspices of the court. The plaintiff and the defendant jointly  Participation complied with legal procedures; second, the selected comparative inspection materials were approved by both the plaintiff and the defendant and cross-examined; third, the judicial appraisal certificate issued by Tianze Judicial Appraisal Institute complied with the legal constitutional requirements, including conforming to the statutory form, and the appraisers had relevant qualifications;  This identification, both in terms of procedure and in substance, is in compliance with the law; if the plaintiff¡¯s application for a new identification is agreed, it will be unfair to the defendant and a waste of judicial resources.¡±

    Lin Ziyao was almost on the verge of wowing!

    Lu Yiming had a serious face, and the law lines were as obvious as a knife carving, which made Lu Yiming look even more fierce.

    In Chen Fan's case, the loan contract used as the basic evidence was found to be forged, and he was destined to lose.  (Remember the site URL: www.hlnovel.com
Didn't finish reading? Add this book to your favoritesI'm a member and bookmarked this chapterCopy the address of this book and recommend it to your friends for pointsChapter error? Click here to report