Add Bookmark | Recommend this book | Back to the book page | My bookshelf | Mobile Reading

Free Web Novel,Novel online - All in hlnovel.com -> Prose -> Hello Miss Lawyer

Chapter 69 Medical Dispute (8)

Previous page        Return to Catalog        Next page

    ?

    Yin Chuan said: "We have presented three pieces of evidence: the first evidence is the acceptance report on the construction of the hospital's safety facilities, which proves that the construction of the hospital's safety facilities fully complies with the relevant documents; the second is the surveillance video on the day the patient fell from the building, which proves that  The time when the nurse left and came back, and the situation that the patient left the ward alone; the third evidence is the notification letter issued by the hospital to the plaintiff, which proves that the hospital has repeatedly informed the plaintiff in written form that the patient suffered from severe depression  symptoms and suicidal tendencies, the patient must be under 24-hour care, and the relevant reminders have been highlighted in bold and underlined."

    "The plaintiff cross-examined evidence." Wu Hui said.

    Wu You said: "There is no objection to the authenticity of the first document, but the subject of the proof has objections. The place where the deceased fell was obviously not equipped with anti-fall facilities, and the first evidence was formed a year ago, so it cannot prove the current construction.  Whether the situation meets the safety standards. There is no objection to the authenticity of the second evidence and the third evidence and the object of the proof."

    "Do both parties have anything to add to the cross-examination?"

    "No." Wu You and Liu Min said in unison.

    "Then enter the stage of court debate, the plaintiff will start first, and don't repeat what I said before."

    "Dear judge, we have not denied that the defendant has set up anti-fall facilities in the ward, but it is an indisputable fact that Mr. Chen fell to his death in the hospital, and the defendant has been emphasizing a concept, that is, the "ward"  and "living area", trying to use this concept to forcibly divide the hospital into two completely different spaces. Is it true that patients have received treatment in the hospital only when they enter the "ward area" mentioned by the defendant? Obviously not. Take a step back  , even if, as the defendant said, all "wards" have been equipped with anti-fall facilities in accordance with relevant regulations, then whether there is a strict distinction between "wards" and "living areas" and whether there are restrictions on entry? Judging from the video data  It is an indisputable fact that Mr. Chen, the father of the two plaintiffs, fell to his death in Hospital a, and the hospital did not conduct any investigations on the "ward" and "living area".  The instructions of the "living area" reminded, so the defendant's first argument is not valid. Second, the plaintiff did not avoid the fact that Mr. Chen was left unattended during the time of the incident because the nurse left for a short time.  , also admits that the defendant has repeatedly reminded us to take care of the patient, but this does not completely exempt the defendant from the obligation to guarantee the safety of the patient. Mr. Chen¡¯s spouse is over seventy years old, and physical reasons do not allow her to accompany her.  The two children of the old man, that is, the two plaintiffs present today, in addition to hiring a nurse to take care of Mr. Chen for 24 hours, have already spent all their time taking care of Mr. Chen except for necessary life and work.  On the day of the incident, the plaintiff, Mr. Chen, was preparing breakfast at home and wanted to deliver the meal to the hospital for his father, Mr. Chen, before breakfast. The plaintiff, Ms. Chen, had to take care of her mother, Ms. Feng, another plaintiff in this case.  According to what I learned from the nurse afterwards, during that time, he just went downstairs to the hospital to buy breakfast, and went to the bathroom by the way. All of the above were just the minimum requirements for a family with seriously ill patients to maintain the most basic daily life, but  In this short 20 minutes, it can be seen from the video that more than one doctor, nurse, and other medical staff passed by Mr. Chen in the hospital, but everyone turned a blind eye to Mr. Chen. Please watch the video carefully.  , Mr. Chen is already very weak due to long-term illness, and has been walking while leaning on the wall, but even so, no medical staff has provided him with the slightest concern. Imagine if there was a doctor at that time  Or the nurse asked, "Old sir, where are you going?  "Will the tragedy happen again?" Wu You paused here, and he took a careful look at Wu Hui's face.

    Liu Min, who had been sitting expressionlessly, frowned slightly at this moment, and his body couldn't help standing upright.

    "I don't think so, at least it will greatly reduce the possibility of Mr. Chen's suicide. In addition, the defendant mentioned that the medical staff repeatedly reminded the plaintiff in writing to provide 24-hour care for Mr. Chen, but this can completely exempt Mr. Chen.  Is it the hospital's duty of care? Don't forget, whether it is legal or moral, it is the responsibility of the hospital to save lives and heal the wounded. This is not the first time that Mr. Chen has been admitted to the defendant's hospital. The doctors and nurses in the relevant departments are very familiar with Mr. Chen  The fact that he suffers from depression is why there are repeated written reminders that the defendant said, so in just 20 minutes, why did no medical staff perform the minimum duty of care for Mr. Chen?  , the notification does not represent the waiver of obligations. In summary, the plaintiff believes that the defendant bears an unshirkable responsibility for the death of Mr. Chen, and requests the court to support the plaintiff's judgment."

    "Well said." Chen Jinyu couldn't help but said.  (Remember the site URL: www.hlnovel.com
Didn't finish reading? Add this book to your favoritesI'm a member and bookmarked this chapterCopy the address of this book and recommend it to your friends for pointsChapter error? Click here to report